|
|
|
|
|
Strict ConstructionismStrict constructionism is a philosophy of judicial interpretation and legal philosophy that holds to the meanings of words and phrases as used when they were written down. Adherents look strictly at the text in question rather than relying on metaphysical ideas such as natural law, or by trying to glean legislative intent from contemporaneous commentaries or legislative debate. U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia is by far the most prominent and controversial advocate of this philosophy. The underlying rationale is that if a legislature truly wants to enact a particular law, they are quite capable of writing it down in plain English and passing it, and it is not a judge's job to play around with legal fictions or psychoanalysis to reconstruct what the legislature's subconscious intent could have been. Thus, for example, Justice Scalia refuses to look at committee reports that often accompany bills to the House or Senate floor, because the report reflects the views of only a small number of legislators and their staff, and often is not read by all the legislators before they vote as the Committee of the Whole. Some argue that the term is vague and difficult to apply. Noting that it largely came into prominence as part of Richard Nixon's presidential campaign, they point to a memo written to Nixon in which the term is explained: - A judge who is a "strict constructionist" in constitutional matters will generally not be favorably inclined toward claims of either criminal defendants or civil rights plaintiffsthe latter two groups having been the principal beneficiaries of the Supreme Court's "broad constructionist" reading of the Constitution. (William H. Rehnquist in a memo to Richard Nixon about Supreme Court nominees)
Based on this, opponents of this view claim the term is mostly just code for judges who tend to support conservative causes, rather than a real theory of judicial interpretation. See Also Originalism Reference Slate article with the Rehnquist quote Politics
|
 |
| |
|
|