Misleading Vividness

The logical fallacy of misleading vividness involves describing some occurrence in vivid detail, even if it is an exceptional occurrence, to convince someone that it is a problem. Though misleading vividness does nothing to support an argument logically, it can have a very strong psychological effect because of a cognitive heuristic called the availability heuristic. Examples:
Anne: "I am giving up extreme sports now that I have children. I think I will take up golf".
Bill: "I wouldn't do that. Do you remember Charles? He was playing golf when he got hit by a golf-cart. It broke his leg, and he fell over, giving himself a concussion. He was in hospital for a week and still walks with a limp. I would stick to paragliding!"
Bill: "Police marksmen should use tasers instead of guns when it's safe to do so.".
Anne: "Can you imagine what would happen if those darts from the taser went into your eyes, piercing your eyeballs, and then if they sent the high voltage through your eyes and brain! It would probably kill you and be much worse than being shot."
This fallacy is a kind of hasty generalization when an inductive generalization is a necessary premise and a single (albeit vivid) example is not sufficient to support such a generalization. See faulty generalization. See also: Texas sharpshooter fallacy, perfect solution fallacy.

 

<< PreviousWord BrowserNext >>
bill (weapon)
george hendrik breitner
canopic jar
sore
appeal to ridicule
alberni quartet
allegri quartet
appetite
sequence analysis
tom clancy's net force
koryu
denying the correlative
fatigue (physical)
algor mortis
suction
rendezvous problem
bibliotheca universalis
suck
rubber hose cryptanalysis
questionable cause
axolotl
acton town tube station
baker street tube station
guilt by association
foreign legion
ju si gyeong
list of malaysian companies
informal logic
blind thrust earthquake
spearman's rank correlation coefficient
highbury & islington station
emily o'reilly
matthew green
bombardier beetle
public schools act
chris bryant
portal vein
public schools act 1868
keelhauling
conscience vote
party lines
eel story
operation keelhaul
corporate governance