| width="40%" align=left|Incumbent | width="20%" align=left|Notes | | a href="/encyclopedia/1539" title="1539">1539 to 1543 | Archbishop George Cromer | Hitherto Catholic Archbishop 1521 to 1538 |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1543" title="1543">1543 to 1552 | Archbishop George Dowdall | Restored, as Catholic Archbishop 1553 to 1558 |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1553" title="1553">1553 to 1553 | Archbishop Hugh Goodacre |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1553" title="1553">1553 to 1563 | Archbishop George Dowdall | Reunited with Roman Catholic establishment |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1563" title="1563">1563 to 1567 | Archbishop Adam Loftus |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1568" title="1568">1568 to 1584 | Archbishop Thomas Lancaster |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1584" title="1584">1584 to 1589 | Archbishop John Long |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1590" title="1590">1590 to 1594/5 | Archbishop John Garvey |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1595" title="1595">1595 to 1613 | Archbishop Henry Ussher |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1613" title="1613">1613 to 1624/5 | Archbishop Christopher Hampton |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1625" title="1625">1625 to 1656 | Archbishop James Ussher |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1656" title="1656">1656 to 1661 | vacant |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1661" title="1661">1661 to 1663 | Archbishop John Bramhall |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1663" title="1663">1663 to 1678 | Archbishop James Margetson |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1678" title="1678">1678 to 1702 | Archbishop Michael Boyle |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1703" title="1703">1703 to 1713 | Archbishop Narcissus Marsh |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1714" title="1714">1714 to 1724 | Archbishop Thomas Lindsay |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1724" title="1724">1724 to 1742 | Archbishop Hugh Boulter |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1742" title="1742">1742 to 1746 | Archbishop John Hoadly |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1747" title="1747">1747 to 1764 | Archbishop George Stone |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1765" title="1765">1765 to 1794 | Archbishop Richard Robinson, Baron Rokeby |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1795" title="1795">1795 to 1800 | Archbishop William Newcome |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1800" title="1800">1800 to 1822 | Archbishop William Stuart |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1822" title="1822">1822 to 1862 | Archbishop John George Beresford |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1862" title="1862">1862 to 1885 | Archbishop Marcus Gervais Beresford |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1886" title="1886">1886 to 1895 | Archbishop Robert Knox |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1893" title="1893">1893 to 1896 | Archbishop Robert Samuel Gregg |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1896" title="1896">1896 to 1911 | Archbishop William Alexander |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1911" title="1911">1911 to 1920 | Archbishop John Baptist Crozier |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1920" title="1920">1920 to 1938 | Archbishop Charles Frederick D'Arcy |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1938" title="1938">1938 to 1938 | Archbishop Charles Godfrey Fitzmaurice Day |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1939" title="1939">1939 to 1959 | Archbishop John Allen Fitzgerald Gregg |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1959" title="1959">1959 to 1969 | Archbishop James McCann |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1969" title="1969">1969 to 1980 | Archbishop George Otto Simms |
| a href="/encyclopedia/1980" title="1980">1980 to 1986 | Archbishop John Ward Armstrong |
| align=top|1986 to present | The Most Reverent Robert Robin Henry Alexander Eames, LL.B., Ph.D., LL.D., D.Litt., D.D Archbishop of Armagh and Primate of All Ireland |