| width="20%"|Tenure | width="40%"|Incumbent | width="20%"|Notes |
| small>27 June 1851 to 31 May 1870 | Thomas Grant, Bishop of Southwark | Ordained 6 July 1851; died in office |
| small>10 January 1871 to 14 June 1881 | James Danell, Bishop of Southwark | Ordained 25 March 1871; died in office |
| small>25 May 1882 to 6 April 1885 | Robert Aston Coffin, CSSR, Bishop of Southwark | Ordained 11 June 1882; installed 27 July 1882; died in office |
| small>26 June 1885 to 12 April 1897 | John Baptist Butt, Bishop of Southwark | Resigned |
| small>9 April 1897 to 11 September 1903 | Francis Alphonsus Bourne, Bishop of Southwark | Appointed Archbishop of Westminster |
| small>12 March 1904 to 18 December 1937 | Peter Emmanuel Amigo, Bishop of Southwark | Ordained 25 March 1904; becoming Archbishop (personal style) |
| small>18 December 1937to 1 October 1949 | Peter Emmanuel Amigo, Archbishop of Southwark | Hitherto Bishop; died in office |
| small>12 December 1949 to 28 May 1965 | Cyril Conrad Cowderoy, Bishop of Southwark | Ordained 21 December 1949; Becoming Archbishop |
| small>28 May 1965 to 10 October 1976 | Cyril Conrad Cowderoy, Archbishop of Southwark | Hitherto Bishop; died in office |
| small>28 March 1977 to 6 November 2003 | Michael George Bowen, Archbishop of Southwark | Bishop of Arundel and Brighton; resigned |
| small>6 November 2003 to present | Kevin John Patrick McDonald, BA, STL, STD, Metropolitan Archbishop of Southwark | Bishop of Northampton; installed 8 December 2003 |