| a href="/encyclopedia/Mayor" title="Mayor">Mayor | Term | | |James Hurtle Fisher |1840 - 1842 |
| |Thomas Wilson |1842 - 1843 |
| |City managed as Government Department |1843 - 1849 |
| |City managed by Commissioners |1849 - 1852 |
| |James Hurtle Fisher |1852 |
| |James Hurtle Fisher |1852 - 1854 |
| |Joseph Hall |1854 - 1855 |
| |John Lazar |1855 - 1858 |
| |William Thompson Sabben |1858 - 1859 |
| |Edmund William Wright |1859 |
| 0 | Edward Bootle Wilbraham Glandfield | 1859 - 1862 |
| 1 | Thomas English | 1862 - 1863 |
| 2 | Samuel Goode | 1863 - 1864 |
| 3 | William Townshend | 1864 - 1866 |
| 4 | Henry Robert Fuller | 1866 - 1869 |
| 5 | Judah Moss Solomon | 1869 - 1871 |
| 6 | Adolph Heinrich Friedrich Bartels | 1871 - 1873 |
| 7 | William Dixon Allot | 1873 - 1874 |
| 8 | John Colton | 1874 - 1875 |
| 9 | Caleb Peacock | 1875 - 1877 |
| 0 | Henry Scott | 1877 - 1878 |
| 1 | William Christie Buik | 1878 - 1879 |
| 2 | Edwin Thomas Smith | 1879 - 1882 |
| 3 | Henry Robert Fuller | 1882 - 1883 |
| 4 | William Bundey | 1883 - 1886 |
| 5 | Edwin Thomas Smith | 1886 - 1887 |
| 6 | Sir Edwin Thomas Smith | 1887 - 1888 |
| 7 | James Shaw | 1888 - 1889 |
| 8 | Lewis Cohen | 1889 - 1890 |
| 9 | Frederick William Bullock | 1891 - 1892 |
| 0 | Charles Wilcox | 1892 - 1894 |
| 1 | Charles Tucker | 1894 - 1898 |
| 2 | Arthur Wellington Ware | 1898 - 1901 |
| 3 | Lewis Cohen | 1901 - 1904 |
| 4 | Theodore Bruce | 1904 - 1907 |
| 5 | Frank Johnson | 1907 - 1909 |
| 6 | Lewis Cohen | 1909 - 1911 |
| 7 | John Lavington Bonython | 1911 - 1913 |
| 8 | Alfred Allen Simpson | 1913 - 1915 |
| 9 | Isaac Isaacs | 1915 - 1917 |
| 0 | Charles Richmond Glover | 1917 - 1919 |