| Name | State | Term of Office | Appointed By | Seat | Reason Service Terminated |
| James Wilson | PA | Oct 5, 1789 - Aug 21, 1798 | Washington | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | died in office |
| John Jay | NY | Oct 19, 1789 - Jun 29, 1795 | Washington | Chief Justice | resigned |
| William Cushing | MA | Feb 2, 1790 - Sep 13, 1810 | Washington | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | died in office |
| John Blair | VA | Feb 2, 1790 - Oct 25, 1795 | Washington | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | resigned |
| John Rutledge | SC | Feb 15, 1790 - Mar 5, 1791 | Washington | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | resigned |
| James Iredell | NC | May 12, 1790 - Oct 20, 1799 | Washington | Associate Justice (Seat #5) | died in office |
| Thomas Johnson | MD | Aug 6, 1792 - Jan 16, 1793 | Washington | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | resigned |
| William Paterson | NJ | Mar 11, 1793 - Sep 9, 1806 | Washington | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | died in office |
| John Rutledge * | SC | Aug 12, 1795 - Dec 15, 1795 | Washington | Chief Justice | recess appointment rejected by Senate |
| Samuel Chase | MD | Feb 4, 1796 - Jun 19, 1811 | Washington | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | died in office |
| Oliver Ellsworth | CT | Mar 8, 1796 - Dec 15, 1800 | Washington | Chief Justice | resigned |
| Bushrod Washington | VA | Feb 4, 1799 - Nov 26, 1829 | Adams | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | died in office |
| Alfred Moore | NC | Apr 21, 1800 - Jan 26, 1804 | Adams | Associate Justice (Seat #5) | resigned |
| John Marshall | VA | Feb 4, 1801 - Jul 6, 1835 | Adams | Chief Justice | died in office |
| William Johnson | SC | May 7, 1804 - Aug 4, 1834 | Jefferson | Associate Justice (Seat #5) | died in office |
| Henry Brockholst Livingston | NY | Jan 20, 1807 - Mar 18, 1823 | Jefferson | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | died in office |
| Thomas Todd | KY | May 4, 1807 - Feb 7, 1826 | Jefferson | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | died in office |
| Gabriel Duval | MD | Nov 23, 1811 - Jan 14, 1835 | Madison | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | resigned |
| Joseph Story | MA | Feb 3, 1812 - Sep 10, 1845 | Madison | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | died in office |
| Smith Thompson * | NY | Dec 9, 1823 - Dec 18, 1843 | Monroe | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | died in office |
| Robert Trimble | KY | Jun 16, 1826 - Aug 25, 1828 | J. Q. Adams | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | died in office |
| John McLean | OH | Jan 11, 1830 - Apr 4, 1861 | Jackson | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | died in office |
| Henry Baldwin | PA | Jan 18, 1830 - Apr 21, 1844 | Jackson | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | died in office |
| James Moore Wayne | GA | Jan 14, 1835 - Jul 5, 1867 | Jackson | Associate Justice (Seat #5) | died in office |
| Roger Brooke Taney | MD | Mar 28, 1836 - Oct 12, 1864 | Jackson | Chief Justice | died in office |
| Philip Pendleton Barbour | VA | May 12, 1836 - Feb 25, 1841 | Jackson | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | died in office |
| John Catron | TN | May 1, 1837 - May 30, 1865 | Van Buren | Associate Justice (Seat #7) | died in office |
| John McKinley | AL | Jan 9, 1838 - Jul 19, 1852 | Van Buren | Associate Justice (Seat #8) | died in office |
| Peter Vivian Daniel | VA | Jan 10, 1842 - May 31, 1860 | Van Buren | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | died in office |
| Samuel Nelson | NY | Feb 27, 1845 - Nov 28, 1872 | Tyler | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | retired |
| Levi Woodbury * | NH | Sep 23, 1845 - Sep 4, 1851 | Polk | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | died in office |
| Robert Cooper Grier | PA | Aug 10, 1846 - Jan 31, 1870 | Polk | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | retired |
| Benjamin Robbins Curtis * | MA | Oct 10, 1851 - Sep 30, 1857 | Fillmore | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | resigned |
| John Archibald Campbell | AL | Apr 11, 1853 - Apr 30, 1861 | Pierce | Associate Justice (Seat #8) | resigned |
| Nathan Clifford | ME | Jan 21, 1858 - Jul 25, 1881 | Buchanan | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | died in office |
| Noah Haynes Swayne | OH | Jan 27, 1862 - Jan 24, 1881 | Lincoln | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | retired |
| Samuel Freeman Miller | IA | Jul 21, 1862 - Oct 13, 1890 | Lincoln | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | died in office |
| David Davis | IL | Dec 10, 1862 - Mar 4, 1877 | Lincoln | Associate Justice (Seat #8) | resigned |
| Stephen Johnson Field | CA | May 20, 1863 - Dec 1, 1897 | Lincoln | Associate Justice (Seat #9) | retired |
| Salmon Portland Chase | OH | Dec 15, 1864 - May 7, 1873 | Lincoln | Chief Justice | died in office |
| William Strong | PA | Mar 15, 1870 - Dec 14, 1880 | Grant | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | retired |
| Joseph Philo Bradley | NJ | Mar 23, 1870 - Jan 22, 1892 | Grant | Associate Justice (Seat #10) | died in office |
| Ward Hunt | NY | Jan 9, 1873 - Jan 27, 1882 | Grant | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | retired |
| Morrison Remick Waite | OH | Mar 4, 1874 - Mar 23, 1888 | Grant | Chief Justice | died in office |
| John Marshall Harlan | KY | Dec 10, 1877 - Oct 14, 1911 | Hayes | Associate Justice (Seat #8) | died in office |
| William Burnham Woods | GA | Jan 5, 1881 - May 14, 1887 | Hayes | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | died in office |
| Thomas Stanley Matthews | OH | May 17, 1881 - Mar 22, 1889 | Garfield | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | died in office |
| Horace Gray | MA | Jan 9, 1882 - Sep 15, 1902 | Arthur | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | died in office |
| Samuel Blatchford | NY | Apr 3, 1882 - Jul 7, 1893 | Arthur | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | died in office |
| Lucius Quintus Cincinnatus Lamar | MS | Jan 18, 1888 - Jan 23, 1893 | Cleveland | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | died in office |
| Melville Weston Fuller | IL | Oct 8, 1888 - Jul 4, 1910 | Cleveland | Chief Justice | died in office |
| David Josiah Brewer | KS | Jan 6, 1890 - Mar 28, 1910 | Harrison | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | died in office |
| Henry Billings Brown | MI | Jan 5, 1891 - May 28, 1906 | Harrison | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | retired |
| George Shiras, Jr. | PA | Oct 10, 1892 - Feb 23, 1903 | Harrison | Associate Justice (Seat #10) | retired |
| Howell Edmunds Jackson | TN | Mar 14, 1893 - Aug 8, 1895 | Harrison | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | died in office |
| Edward Douglass White | LA | Mar 12, 1894 - Dec 18, 1910 | Cleveland | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | elevated to Chief Justice |
| Rufus Wheeler Peckham | NY | Jan 6, 1896 - Oct 24, 1909 | Cleveland | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | died in office |
| Joseph McKenna | CA | Jan 26, 1898 - Jan 5, 1925 | McKinley | Associate Justice (Seat #9) | retired |
| Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. | MA | Dec 8, 1902 - Jan 12, 1932 | T. Roosevelt | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | retired |
| William Rufus Day | OH | Mar 2, 1903 - Nov 13, 1922 | T. Roosevelt | Associate Justice (Seat #10) | retired |
| William Henry Moody | MA | Dec 17, 1906 - Nov 20, 1910 | T. Roosevelt | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | resigned |
| Horace Harmon Lurton | TN | Jan 3, 1910 - Jul 12, 1914 | Taft | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | died in office |
| Charles Evans Hughes | NY | Oct 10, 1910 - Jun 10, 1916 | Taft | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | resigned |
| Edward Douglass White | LA | Dec 19, 1910 - May 19, 1921 | Taft | Chief Justice | died in office |
| Willis Van Devanter | WY | Jan 3, 1911 - Jun 2, 1937 | Taft | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | died in office |
| Joseph Rucker Lamar | GA | Jan 3, 1911 - Jan 2, 1916 | Taft | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | died in office |
| Mahlon Pitney | NJ | Mar 18, 1912 - Dec 31, 1922 | Taft | Associate Justice (Seat #8) | resigned |
| James Clark McReynolds | TN | Oct 12, 1914 - Jan 31, 1941 | Wilson | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | assumed senior status |
| Louis Dembitz Brandeis | MA | Jun 5, 1916 - Feb 13, 1939 | Wilson | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | assumed senior status |
| John Hessin Clarke | OH | Oct 9, 1916 - Sep 18, 1922 | Wilson | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | resigned |
| William Howard Taft | OH | Jul 11, 1921 - Feb 3, 1930 | Harding | Chief Justice | resigned |
| George Sutherland | UT | Oct 2, 1922 - Jan 17, 1938 | Harding | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | assumed senior status |
| Pierce Butler | MN | Jan 2, 1923 - Nov 16, 1939 | Harding | Associate Justice (Seat #10) | died in office |
| Edward Terry Sanford | TN | Feb 19, 1923 - Mar 8, 1930 | Harding | Associate Justice (Seat #8) | died in office |
| Harlan Fiske Stone | NY | Mar 2, 1925 - Jul 2, 1941 | Coolidge | Associate Justice (Seat #9) | elevated to Chief Justice |
| Charles Evans Hughes | NY | Feb 24, 1930 - Jun 30, 1941 | Hoover | Chief Justice | retired |
| Owen Josephus Roberts | PA | Jun 2, 1930 - Jul 31, 1945 | Hoover | Associate Justice (Seat #8) | resigned |
| Benjamin Nathan Cardozo | NY | Mar 31, 1932 - Jul 9, 1938 | Hoover | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | died in office |
| Hugo LaFayette Black | AL | Aug 19, 1937 - Sep 17, 1971 | F. Roosevelt | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | died in office |
| Stanley Forman Reed | KY | Jan 31, 1938 - Feb 25, 1957 | F. Roosevelt | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | assumed senior status |
| Felix Frankfurter | MA | Jan 30, 1939 - Aug 28, 1962 | F. Roosevelt | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | assumed senior status |
| William Orville Douglas | CT | Apr 17, 1939 - Nov 12, 1975 | F. Roosevelt | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | assumed senior status |
| Francis William Murphy | MI | Feb 5, 1940 - Jul 19, 1949 | F. Roosevelt | Associate Justice (Seat #10) | died in office |
| Harlan Fiske Stone | NY | Jul 3, 1941 - Apr 22, 1946 | F. Roosevelt | Chief Justice | died in office |
| James Francis Byrnes | SC | Jul 8, 1941 - Oct 3, 1942 | F. Roosevelt | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | resigned |
| Robert Houghwout Jackson | NY | Jul 11, 1941 - Oct 9, 1954 | F. Roosevelt | Associate Justice (Seat #9) | died in office |
| Wiley Blount Rutledge | IA | Feb 15, 1943 - Sep 10, 1949 | F. Roosevelt | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | died in office |
| Harold Hitz Burton | OH | Oct 1, 1945 - Oct 13, 1958 | Truman | Associate Justice (Seat #8) | assumed senior status |
| Frederick Moore Vinson | KY | Jun 24, 1946 - Sep 8, 1953 | Truman | Chief Justice | died in office |
| Thomas Campbell Clark | TX | Aug 24, 1949 - Jun 12, 1967 | Truman | Associate Justice (Seat #10) | assumed senior status |
| Sherman Minton | IN | Oct 12, 1949 - Oct 15, 1956 | Truman | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | assumed senior status |
| Earl Warren * | CA | Oct 5, 1953 - Jun 23, 1969 | Eisenhower | Chief Justice | assumed senior status |
| John Marshall Harlan II | NY | Mar 28, 1955 - Sep 23, 1971 | Eisenhower | Associate Justice (Seat #9) | assumed senior status |
| William Joseph Brennan * | NJ | Oct 16, 1956 - Jul 20, 1990 | Eisenhower | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | assumed senior status |
| Charles Evans Whittaker | MO | Mar 25, 1957 - Mar 31, 1962 | Eisenhower | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | assumed senior status |
| Potter Stewart * | OH | Oct 14, 1958 - Jul 3, 1981 | Eisenhower | Associate Justice (Seat #8) | assumed senior status |
| Byron Raymond White | CO | Apr 16, 1962 - Jun 28, 1993 | Kennedy | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | assumed senior status |
| Arthur Joseph Goldberg | IL | Oct 1, 1962 - Jul 25, 1965 | Kennedy | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | resigned |
| Abe Fortas | TN | Oct 4, 1965 - May 14, 1969 | Johnson | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | resigned |
| Thurgood Marshall | NY | Oct 2, 1967 - Oct 1, 1991 | Johnson | Associate Justice (Seat #10) | assumed senior status |
| Warren Earl Burger | VA | Jun 23, 1969 - Sep 26, 1986 | Nixon | Chief Justice | assumed senior status |
| Harry Andrew Blackmun | MN | Jun 9, 1970 - Aug 3, 1994 | Nixon | Associate Justice (Seat #2) | assumed senior status |
| Lewis Franklin Powell, Jr. | VA | Jan 7, 1972 - Jun 26, 1987 | Nixon | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | assumed senior status |
| William Hubbs Rehnquist | AZ | Jan 7, 1972 - Sep 26, 1986 | Nixon | Associate Justice (Seat #9) | elevated to Chief Justice |
| John Paul Stevens | IL | Dec 19, 1975 | Ford | Associate Justice (Seat #3) | |
| Sandra Day O'Connor | AZ | Sep 25, 1981 | Reagan | Associate Justice (Seat #8) | |
| William Hubbs Rehnquist | AZ | Sep 26, 1986 | Reagan | Chief Justice | |
| Antonin Scalia | VA | Sep 26, 1986 | Reagan | Associate Justice (Seat #9) | |
| Anthony McLeod Kennedy | CA | Feb 18, 1988 | Reagan | Associate Justice (Seat #4) | |
| David Hackett Souter | NH | Oct 9, 1990 | G. H. W. Bush | Associate Justice (Seat #1) | |
| Clarence Thomas | GA | Oct 23, 1991 | G. H. W. Bush | Associate Justice (Seat #10) | |
| Ruth Joan Bader Ginsburg | NY | Aug 10, 1993 | Clinton | Associate Justice (Seat #6) | |
| Stephen Gerald Breyer | MA | Aug 3, 1994 | Clinton | Associate Justice (Seat #2) |